Do you often add a sidebar to your forum? If so, is it displayed on all pages or just the forum index (or other specific pages)? Additionally, what are some of the things you include in the sidebar?
I don't use sidebars because my members tend to complain about them every single time. I, on the other hand, would prefer to use them.
I absolutely use a side column on my forums, on the homepage and forumhome only. I don't like it on forum display or showthread. I typically use mine for affiliate links/images, adsense, extra navigation links (I try to leave my navbar as default as possible), etc. On my designs site, I use it to also desplay screenshots of my latest free releases. I never use it for forum stats, as they are already available in the WGO box. Latest threads / latest posts is a waste. You can get that info by clicking on the New Posts link :p
I like to have a nice looking sidebar on all pages. The stuff i add there is different but on most sites i have added some information, links, poll and latest threads. Sometimes i also have some stats.
I agree. I personally think it looks awful when the forum statistics are moved to a sidebar and absent from the footer (the last thing you see at the bottom of the forum is the "View Forum Leaders" link).
I like to use the sidebar on the forumhome. It provides an easy way to link to CMS pages that users might otherwise not find. I can also put links that people might frequently be searching for and by making a link blatantly obvious, I end up with a less frustrated user.
I like sidebars and have used them in the past for other info that might be useful. My members have always hated them so I just got rid of them. The next theme I get I will get one integrated into it so it is less noticeable.
Exactly. After all of the whining and complaining, I decided that it would be best to get rid of them.
I wonder why your members don't like them. It seems that everybody here loves our sidebar. It must be a difference in our audiences.
After a while I found it not worth listening to them. Then they wanted to have the info I had in the sidebar somewhere else...just can't win haha
Lot of plusses to the right sidebar column.. The primary ones are: 1) The column doesn't break up the eye. 2) Less scrolling to get to the sidebar navigation.
I use sidebar columns on both forumhome and homepages on my sites. Definitely needed for selling ad space as well as some navigational help as well. I like left side columns though for some reason. Maybe because I'm left handed
A solution to the some members want it some members don't want it problem is to provide the same skin with and without the sidebar feature. That is what we do here on AA, though I'm not sure how many people are actually using the sidebarless version.